All Or Nothing is a true story of Hailey Rose, who before coming a pornstar found herself using her college campus as a place of sexual exploration. The film tells the true story of a girl who matches with three frat boys/housemates on a dating app, as they jokingly try to pull a fellow student for a BBBG foursome... It's only when Hailey reacts with enthusiasm to their offer that the boys start to doubt if they're up for her, and begin to question their loyalty to each other.

Hailey decides to test each of the guys individually, seeking them out out for one-on-one sexual experiences, ranging from hot car sex, to a risky muffled bedroom fuck, to a public school gym locker room until the boys realize they've all been played behind their backs, and decide to confront Hailey in a classroom to figure out what she's been doing. It's there that she convinces them to follow through on their original plan... It's All or Nothing, right?